Tuesday, October 13, 2009

Palestine Israel conflict

Prompt: Failure to embrace change will often result in more harm than good.

The Palestine-Israel crisis is a key example where change has not been embraced, resulting in enormous problems and extreme conflict.

Although Israel was previously occupied by the Jews and they have religious ties with it, I don’t believe this should have given/should give them the right to reclaim it as their own. 

The Jewish people were forced to leave their homes after being exiled by the Babylonians. By the time large numbers of Jews began returning to their religious homeland (in the late 1800s), it had long been inhabited by established Arab settlements. 

The Jewish people affectively colonised the land and made it their own. Palestinian territories have decreased considerably and now include two main regions: the Gaza strip and the West Bank, however these territories are currently considered to be occupied by the Israelis. 

The colonisation of Israel can be compared to numerous countries (including our own), which were settled regardless of other occupants that inhabited the land. For example, the United States was settled by the pilgrims who forced the Native American’s/first nation’s from their land and set up the US that we know today, (killing many Native American’s in the process.) European settlers also imposed their authority and strength on the aborigines in Australia, and they too were forced from their land to make way for the European colonies. 

Although the original inhabitants (the Australian aboriginals and the Native Americans) probably deserve to get their land back, but it would be disadvantageous and also completely unrealistic to expect the other established cultures with to vacate the land, their homes and birthplace and move elsewhere. However, this is pretty much what has occurred in Israel. The Jewish people were the original inhabitants of Israel, however their absence was so long that in reality they forced the Arabs from their land, which would be unthinkable in societies such as our own. I realise that this was how our nation was created in the first place but the resettlement of the Jews occurred at a time when colonisation was decreasing and was (in a way) becoming less acceptable (I think…)

Basically, the Jews should not have been forced from their land in the first place however, just like many other native inhabitants, they were. The Arab culture that then developed in Israel in following centuries was so advanced that it should not have been taken over. Also, colonialism was far less acceptable and an unrealistic option that becoming less popular as countries began to gain independence from settling empires/nations. The Arabs should not have been expected to move from the society they had created. 

Ultimately, (not to sound anti-semitic or anything) but the Jews did not embrace the change and instead have attempted to resist it and have basically attempted to revert back to their settlement that had been absent from for over 1000+ years. This has obviously had disastrous affects for Israelis but more significantly for the Arabs. It has also made it difficult for either culture develop and advance their civilisations.

No comments:

Post a Comment